Evidence for Policy Making: Clinical Appropriateness Study of Lumbar Spine MRI Prescriptions Using RAND Appropriateness Method

Background MRI is a new and expensive diagnostic technology, which has been used increasingly all over the world. Low back pain is a worldwide prevalent disorder and MRI technique is one of the several ways to diagnose it. This paper aims to identify the appropriateness of lumbar spine MRI prescriptions in Shiraz teaching hospitals using standardized RAND Appropriateness Method (RAM) criteria in ۲۰۱۲.   Methods This study consisted of two phases. The first phase involved a qualitative enquiry and the second phase had a quantitative cross-sectional nature. In the first phase RAM was used for developing lumbar spine MRI indications and scenarios. In the second phase, the finalized scenarios were compared with the history and physical examination of ۳۰۰ patients with low back pain. The rate of appropriateness of lumbar spine MRI prescription was then calculated.   Results Of ۳۰۰ cases of lumbar spine MRI prescriptions, approximately ۱۶۷ (۵۶%) were considered inappropriate, ۷۲ (۲۴%) were uncertain, and ۶۱ (۲۰%) were deemed to be appropriate. The economic burden of inappropriate prescriptions was calculated at ۸۸,۰۰۹,۰۰۰ Rials. In addition, the types of expertise and physical examination were considered as related factors to appropriateness of prescriptions.   Conclusion In conclusion, a large proportion of lumbar spine MRI prescriptions, which result in financial burden on the insurance companies and the patients alike is unnecessary. This study suggests that policy makers consider this evidence while decision-making. Our findings highlight the imperative role of Health Technology Assessment (HTA) and Clinical Practice Guidelines (CPGs). As a result, developing local clinical guidelines may create the commitment needed in physicians in prescribing appropriate prescriptions within the health sector. The study further recommends that appropriate scenarios should be considered as a criterion for payment and reimbursement.

Keywords:

MRI Prescription , Lumbar Spine , RAND Appropriateness Method , Evidence , Clinical Practice Guideline , Shiraz